Rock Paper Scissors

Title: Rock Paper Scissors

Author: Alice Feeney

Genre: Psychological/Domestic Thriller

Published: 2021

Obtained: Barnes & Noble

The marriage of Mr. and Mrs. Wright has been in trouble for a while. Adam Wright is a work-obsessed screenwriter with facial blindness; he doesn’t recognize any familiar faces, including his own wife’s. The couple has some optimism for their marriage, however, when they win a weekend getaway to Scotland to celebrate their anniversary. Adam’s wife writes him a letter each year, along with a traditional gift—but she never gives him the letters to read. This anniversary she decides to change that. Their romantic getaway takes a wild turn of lies, deceit, suspense and a lurking stranger in the remote Scottish landscape.

Rock Paper Scissors was at the top of my read list this year. I have a love for all things Scottish, mysterious and suspenseful. This novel had a few really strong bits, but also failed to deliver on some of the anticipated twists and turns. I liked the build-up of the characters, the setting and the general storyline. I found a lot of the story unbelievable to the point where it was distracting from the heart of the story. I didn’t particularly like Mr. or Mrs. Wright, which made it hard to always care what happened to them. And Adam’s facial blindness syndrome was a bizarre, albeit convenient, tidbit.

I typically enjoy a novel that bounces between different POVs with the characters; however, this one was difficult for me because I honestly wasn’t rooting for anyone…except Bob, the dog! I did like the way Feeney incorporated the letters from wife to husband—I thought this was a compelling way to give the reader some insight on the marriage history. I thought Feeney also did a nice job of peeling back each layer of secrecy between the characters.

Again, the setting was outstanding. The eerie and isolated church in the remote part of Scotland was perfect for a fast-paced, twisty read. As much as I loved the atmospheric descriptions and the tension that Feeney managed to build with the remote location…it all seemed to build up to nothing. I wanted more to happen after a suspenseful build up to the characters going into the creepy wine cellar and out into the Scottish landscape.

This was the first Alice Feeney book I’ve read, and I thoroughly enjoyed her actual writing. It was witty and twisty and full of great one-liners. She turns a phrase so well, that I think that’s what kept me so engaged in the novel. What I didn’t love was the bit about Adam’s facial blindness. I just felt it was a cheap way to make the character unreliable—it reminded me of how so many authors use the woman-is-an-undependable-drunk strategy when wanting unreliable narration. I found myself so distracted from the story and went down a rabbit hole on the internet to find out if facial blindness would play out the way it does for Adam. I’ll let you be the judge for yourself—but for me, it was a stretch.

I am giving Rock Paper Scissors 2.5 stars. I didn’t dislike the story, but I found I ended with a lot more questions than answers. I wasn’t really surprised by much in the book—at least not by anything that was purposely meant to shock me as a reader. I loved the setting, and I loved a lot of the prose. I paired this read with a red blend called Troublemaker. It is a full, dark red with hints of fruit, spices and rich caramel. I love a good syrah or zinfandel—so naturally I loved this blend where both of those could be really tasted! It also doesn’t hurt that it’s strong (14.5%)—which really helped me get through this one.